A very mistaken concept
The planets blackbody equilibrium temperatures (Te planets effective temperatures) CANNOT BE CONSIDERED as the planets without atmosphere average (Tmean) surface temperatures.
It is a very mistaken concept. NO PLANET HAS A UNIFORM SURFACE TEMPERATURE.
And it is proven by observations.
For Mars Te.mars = 210 K and Tsat.mean.mars = 210 K these two temperatures – the THEORETICAL mathematical abstraction’s value of Te.mars to be equal to the satellite MEASURED Tsat.mean.mars is a COINCIDENCE.
These planets Te and Tsat temperatures equality is never observed again in the entire (measured) solar system.
Also it should be underlined that Tsat.mean.mars = 210 K is not planet’s Mars uniform surface temperature.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Surface.. temp.. min……mean…..max
Kelvin………........130 K….210 K… 308 K
Instead of accepting this FUNDAMENTAL OBSERVATION as an undeniable fact, we are comforting ourselves trying to explain the observed differences between the every planet calculated Te and the satellite measured Tsat.mean.planet.
Thus for Earth we have the greenhouse warming effect theories.
For some planets (Jupiter, Saturn, Neptune) we have the huge inner sources of heat theories.
For some other cases we have the tidal warming theories (Jupiter’s and Saturn’s satellites).
For every planet-case we are looking for an excuse-explanation, so to keep to the MISTAKEN CONCEPT about the Te = Tmean equality for planets without atmosphere.
But the truth is, there is not any measurable greenhouse warming effect on the Earth’s surface.
The Earth’s atmosphere is very thin and it is very transparent both ways – in and out.
And as for carbon dioxide – there are only traces of CO2 in Earth’s atmosphere. Only traces…
Planet effective temperature Te and Planet average surface temperature Tsat.mean are completely different physics terms
Planet effective temperature Te is the planet surface uniform temperature in Kelvin when assuming planet emits the incident on the sunlit side solar flux's energy uniformly distributed on the entire planet's surface (the sunlit and the dark).
Therefore when we are referring to the planet effective temperature Te we have in consideration a uniform temperature at which the entire planet surface emits the same amount of the incident on the planet energy as the planet does with its actual temperatures distribution on its entire surface.
So the planet effective temperature is calculated by the equation:
Te = [ (1-a) S /4σ ]¹∕ ⁴
a - is the planet's surface average albedo (dimensionless)
S - is the solar flux (W/m²)
σ = 5,67*10⁻⁸ W/m²K⁴, the Stefan-Boltzmann constant
What we do here is that we average on the entire planet's surface the total energy of incoming solar flux, and then, using the Stefan-Boltzmann emission law, calculate the planet's surface effective temperature Te.
Te is a theoretical uniform temperature which does not exist and cannot be measured on the real planet's surface, because planet's surface cannot have a uniform temperature.
On the other hand, Tsat.mean is an average planet surface temperature in Kelvin.
Tsat.mean is a satellite measured planet average surface temperature.
To have Tsat.mean satellite performs countless measurements on countless planet surface spots.
Then computers produce the planet average surface temperature Tsat.mean.
Tsat.mean is not a planet uniform temperature, so it cannot be compared with the theoretical mathematical abstraction planet surface effective temperature Te.
Planet effective temperature Te and planet average mean surface temperature Tsat.mean both are planet solar flux and planet albedo dependent values.
The difference is that Te is ONLY planet solar flux and planet albedo dependent value.
As for Tsat.mean it is NOT ONLY planet solar flux and planet albedo dependent value.
Tsat.mean is also a planet rotational spin N and planet surface specific heat cp dependent value.
That is why we observe for the slow rotating Mercury and Moon the Tsat.mean satellite measured average surface temperatures being LOWER than the Mercury's and Moon's Te effective temperatures.
For the faster rotating planets and moons in the solar system we observe Tsat.mean temperatures being MUCH HIGHER than the uniform theoretical effective temperatures.
And that is why Earth's satellite measured average surface temperature Tmean = 288 K, when Earth's effective temperature Te = 255 K.
And that is why the difference 288 Κ - 255 Κ = Δ33°C does not exist in the real world.
There is not a Δ33°C greenhouse warming effect on the Earth's surface.
The PLANET SURFACE ROTATIONAL WARMING PHENOMENON is what happens.